Mistletoe Murders: Release date, cast, plot, & Everything we know About Sarah Drew’s Whodunnit Series

The highly anticipated holiday mystery series Mistletoe Murders is gearing up to bring a festive twist to crime-solving, and fans are already buzzing with excitement! 

Starring Sarah Drew, this upcoming Hallmark series promises to deliver a thrilling combination of Christmas charm and nail-biting mystery. 

The latest exciting news is that the premiere date for Mistletoe Murders has been confirmed, and fans can expect it to debut soon. This new series, adapted from the beloved Audible Original podcast by Ken Cuperus, is set to be a must-watch for lovers of cozy mysteries. Hallmark Media is delving into new territory with this Christmas Noir, a genre mash-up that will keep viewers on the edge of their seats while wrapped in holiday spirit.

Want to know more? We’ll dive into the cast details, plot twists, and what makes this series unique. Keep an eye out for updates as we continue to reveal more exciting insights leading up to its premiere—there’s so much more to uncover!

Stay tuned—as soon as new details emerge, we’ll be here to keep you in the loop!

Release date & Where to Watch

The six-episode holiday series is set to debut on Hallmark+ on Thursday, Oct. 31, 2024.

Plot

Mistletoe Murders centers on Emily Lane, a charming small-town shop owner with a sharp wit and a hidden past. Emily runs "Under the Mistletoe," a year-round Christmas-themed store in the quaint tourist town of Fletcher’s Grove. While she appears cheerful and friendly, her inner voice reveals a sardonic sense of humor, a sharp intellect, and a keen eye for the details others often miss. However, Emily's life takes a twist when she becomes intrigued by a series of local murders and decides to investigate on her own.

As she delves deeper into these crimes, she catches the attention of Detective Sam Wilner, a clever local cop who has a soft spot for Emily—and the feeling isn't entirely one-sided. Together, they work to uncover the truth behind the mysterious deaths, all while Emily struggles to keep her own secrets from unraveling.

Based on the Audible series of the same name, the show blends light-hearted charm with thrilling mystery as Emily balances running her beloved shop and solving crimes that hit too close to home. With a hidden past that could destroy her new life, Emily walks a fine line between uncovering the town's dark secrets and protecting her own.

Cast

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Hallmark+ (@hallmarkplus)

• Sarah Drew as Emily Lane (Branching Out, Guiding Emily)
• Peter Mooney as Sam Wilner
• Sierra Marilyn Riley as Violet
• Jean Yoon 
• Lara Amersey (Operation Nutcracker) as June Hubble
• David Hewlett (The Shape of Water)
• Tom Cavanagh (The Flash)
• Jake Epstein (Suits) 
• Steven Lund (Schitt’s Creek)
• Isaac Kragten as Pete
• Arlene Duncan as Vera Van Dorne
• Kylee Evans
• Jeremy Durgana as Christmas DJ

Trailer

There’s no trailer yet, but as soon as one is released, we’ll have it here for you. Stay tuned!

Filming

Production for Mistletoe Murders kicked off in June 2024, with filming taking place in Toronto and its surrounding areas. Sarah Drew shared a wrap photo from the set to celebrate the completion of season one. Check it out below!

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Sarah Drew (@thesarahdrew)

Behind the Scenes

Mistletoe Murders is created by Ken Cuperus, the mind behind the popular Audible podcast of the same name, and also known for his work on Carter. Joining him as executive producers are Michelle Melanson (The Next Step), Jocelyn Hamilton (Burden of Truth), and Robbie David (Dark Matter).

Adding to the powerhouse team is award-winning director Grant Harvey (The Way Home), who brings his distinct vision to the series. The show is produced by Lionsgate Canada and Headspinner Productions, with Grant Harvey also serving as co-executive producer alongside the talented team.