Million Dollar Secret Finale: Who won the $1 Million Prize in the High-Stakes Reality Show?
After weeks of deception, emotional eliminations, and wild strategy, Million Dollar Secret has finally revealed its first-ever winner—and reality TV’s newest millionaire. Hosted by The Tick star Peter Serafinowicz, the show brought together 12 strangers in a mansion dubbed “The Stag,” where each contestant was assigned a wooden box — but only one held a life-changing $1 million. The twist?
Whoever had the money had to keep it a secret to avoid elimination, while the others tried to figure out who the secret millionaire was. Let’s break it down and see who the winner is—and who left the finale empty-handed.
Who was Crowned the Secret Millionaire?
On April 9, 2025, the final two episodes of the season dropped, revealing that 29-year-old Cara Kies, an In-N-Out cook from Los Angeles, was the ultimate winner. Her quiet determination and strategic gameplay helped her outwit the competition and claim the grand prize.
The finale featured the remaining contestants — Cara, Corey Niles, Samantha Hubbard, and Sydnee Falkner — facing intense challenges and a high-stakes final game involving strategic box swaps. Cara pulled off a bold move by playing into Corey’s suspicions, allowing him to take her box and then switching it back — ensuring the money stayed with her.
“Cara, you are the final millionaire,” host Serafinowicz announced as the final boxes were opened. He then turned to a shocked Corey and Samantha, adding, “And she has two sisters,” confirming the clue that had misled the finalists and secured Cara’s win.
How the Final game Played out
In episode seven, Jaimi and Kyle were eliminated — Jaimi by group vote, and Kyle by a “kill shot” from the millionaire, who at that point was Cara. That left four players: Cara, Corey, Samantha, and Sydnee. Samantha had a clue stating the secret millionaire had two sisters, which led her to wrongly suspect Corey.
Meanwhile, Cara lied about only having one sister, hiding her identity masterfully. The penultimate challenge paired Samantha with Corey and Cara with Sydnee in a laser beam obstacle course. Cara deliberately lost, betting that her social alliances would keep her safe — a gamble that paid off, as Sydnee was voted out.
A game of Strategy and Misdirection
The final three then faced a needle-threading task, which Samantha failed, eliminating her from the box-swapping portion of the finale. But she was allowed to speak and influence the others — not that it helped.
Cara then enacted her brilliant plan. Corey swapped his box with hers, believing she was the millionaire. Then, in her turn, Cara swapped them back. When the time came to open the boxes, the million-dollar prize was back in Cara’s hands.
Runners-Up React to the Loss
While Cara celebrated her life-changing win, the runners-up, Corey and Samantha, were left grappling with the defeat. “I really felt in my heart that the money was going to be there. And it hurts bad. It kills. But she played a good game. And she got me,” Corey admitted.
Samantha, despite finishing third, had a strong social presence throughout the game and helped shape much of the final outcome, even if it wasn’t in her favor.
Fans React to Cara's win in Million Dollar Secret Finale
The finale of Million Dollar Secret sent shockwaves through viewers — and social media lit up with reactions after Cara Kies was crowned the winner of the $1 million prize.
Many praised her performance, calling it a masterclass in deception and strategy. One X user, @ReallyUnbiased, wrote, “Cara played a masterclass of a competitive reality tv game. One of the best games I’ve seen in a LONG time across any show. Well played and well deserved.”
Cara played a masterclass of a competitive reality tv game. One of the best games I’ve seen in a LONG time across any show. Well played and well deserved. #MillionDollarSecret
— Unbiased Reality (@ReallyUnbiased) April 9, 2025
Meanwhile, @bratzzy_dolly summed it up simply, “In conclusion money is not loud! I'm so happy for Cara. She deserves the money.”
In conclusion money is not loud!
— Doll✨💕 (@bratzzy_dolly) April 9, 2025
I'm so happy for cara.
She deserves the money.#MillionDollarSecret
But not everyone was celebrating. Some fans expressed disappointment for the runners-up — especially Samantha.
One user wrote, “I wanted Sam to win, she was really good, ruthless when she needed to be, she read 99% of the situations correctly, I think she would've won if she hadn't allowed herself to be bamboozled by Cara's quiet and demure vibe.”
I wanted Sam to win, she was really good, ruthless when she needed to be, she read 99% of the situations correctly, I think she would've won if she hadn't allowed herself to be bamboozled by Cara's quiet and demure vibe.#MillionDollarSecret
— Annalise Keating's Uppity African#29🇵🇸 🇨🇩 🇸🇩 (@callmepatrisha_) April 9, 2025
Cara’s gameplay clearly left an impact — and fans are still buzzing about the wild ride that led to her million-dollar moment.
What’s next for Cara?
While Cara has yet to reveal how she’ll spend her winnings, one thing’s for sure—she’s gone from In-N-Out cook to millionaire overnight. With smarts, subtlety, and just the right amount of deception, she sealed her place in reality TV history.
All eight episodes of Million Dollar Secret are now available to stream on Netflix. Check out the recaps of Episode 1, Episode 2, Episode 3, Episode 4, Episode 5, & Episode 6.
Related
Most Popular
Most Popular